Am I A Woman?

My mom recently told me that she “knows for a fact” I’m not a woman on the inside. As an anonymous transwoman’s mother said to her child, she (the transwoman) cannot be a woman because she hasn’t grown up as a girl and experienced the unique and challenging life of being female from birth. It is insulting to womanhood, the mother said, that her trans child thought of herself as a woman.

I hear these concerns loud and clear. It is true that I don’t know what it’s like to be biologically female. I’ll never fully know in this life, even if I transition. I wasn’t raised or socialized among women as a girl. My experience of life has been in the male world. However, does that really un-authenticate me? Yes, I’m missing that wealth of experience, but there are plenty of natal women who are also denied the fullness of a female experience. What about girls whose parents wanted a boy and therefore raise their daughter as a son? Can that girl not grow into womanhood? Is it too late for her just because she is missing particular experiences? Sure, she may have to try harder than other girls, but isn’t she still able to enter the world of Woman?

When my mom told me she “knows for a fact” I’m not a woman, she meant more than just this. She also meant that my core isn’t female in the first place. I can’t really argue with her because people have to either trust me about my own inner life or not, and I can’t control whether they believe me or not. What is hurtful is that she assumes that my transgenderism is her son wants to be a girl. I don’t want to “become” a girl. I don’t want to be anything except myself! I don’t want to “crossdress” – I want to dress, in clothes that I actually like. I don’t want to “make” my personality more feminine – I want to let the femininity that’s already there express itself! Some transgender people would disagree with me, but I feel that being transsexual doesn’t mean “making” yourself into the person you want to be – I feel that it is becoming the person you already are.

I could be wrong. After all, I’m still in the process of looking to God to tell me who I am. However, I strongly believe that my inner gender identity is truly female. Maybe God could change it to male, but in the meantime I have a core that will grow into a woman if I allow it to flourish.


4 thoughts on “Am I A Woman?

  1. I can relate to how that conversation went… I told my parents recently. One blamed it on my becoming a writer to early in life, the other on spiritual endeavors.

    It’s comforting that they are trying to understand, or so I was told. Truthfully ‘comfort’ is not how I’d describe the conversation. Sometimes I just get tired of understanding how others react to MY problems. Isn’t having the problem bad enough?


    • Yeah, it’s intellectually comforting to recognize that your parents’ strong reaction is probably coming from how much they care about you. However, that doesn’t really help with the feeling of invalidation when the two people you most need to understand you keep trying to figure out which “perversion” box you fall into.

      I know this sounds corny, but let’s both let our inner beauty shine forth so that our parents can see the real us starting with our souls. I know my parents will be inevitably freaked out the more I start looking, acting, and dressing completely different, but hopefully if they can see my soul more clearly, they will be less confused about where all this “effeminacy” is coming from. Hang in there!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s